Rethinking capital punishment for drug offences in Malaysia

Publications

Rethinking capital punishment for drug offences in Malaysia

17 November 2026
Anti-Death Penalty Asia Network (ADPAN)
Eleos Justice

The abolition of the mandatory death penalty in 2023 marked a watershed moment in criminal justice reform in Malaysia. The reforms narrowed the range of offences that carry the death penalty and gave judges discretion over whether to impose it. A temporary jurisdiction granted to the Federal Court to review all existing death sentences has substantially reduced the number of people on death row. These changes opened the way for sentencing based on the circumstances of each case, and laid the groundwork for further reform. Malaysia now faces a clear policy question: does the law as it stands adequately address concerns about the death penalty, especially in relation to drug offences, or is further legislative reform needed, including removing the death penalty as a sentencing option altogether?

This brief answers that question using legal and policy research and five focus group discussions (FGDs) held between May and July 2026. The 31 participants came from the legal, health and other professions, religious and faith-based organisations, business, youth groups and community-based organisations. This brief focuses on the death penalty for drug trafficking. It does not address capital punishment for other offences.

Across all focus groups, the dominant view was that the death penalty should not apply to drug trafficking. This included participants who would keep it for other serious crimes. Participants raised concerns about perceived corruption in the criminal justice system, unequal access to justice, inconsistent sentencing, and discriminatory law enforcement, all of which can affect who is sentenced to death. They pointed to the law’s impact on vulnerable couriers, low-income communities, women facing economic insecurity, and marginalised ethnic communities. Above all, theyquestioned whether the death penalty ever reaches those who organise and profit from the drug trade.

This research finds that participants’ attitudes towards the death penalty were also shifting. Some said they had been influenced by alternative sources of information, particularly news of Malaysians executed abroad. These cases also expose an inconsistency: Malaysia seeks clemency for its citizens facing execution overseas while retaining the death penalty for the same offences at home. This suggests there is room for wider public engagement on reform. Participants also placed strong emphasis on rehabilitation, and those from all five faith traditions agreed that drug couriers should not face the death penalty.
This policy brief recommends abolishing the death penalty for drug trafficking as a first step towards abolition for all offences. Stronger sentencing safeguards could make outcomes fairer and more consistent. However, they cannot remove the structural inequalities these findings reveal, nor can they resolve the human rights concerns that the death penalty raises. International human rights standards limit capital punishment to the ‘most serious crimes’, a threshold that drug offences do not meet.

On the other hand, abolition would eliminate the risk of irreversible executions for drug offences, bring Malaysia closer to international standards, and maintain criminal accountability through proportionate prison sentences. To support this change, this brief recommends measures across all three branches of government. Parliament should amend the law to remove the death penalty for drug trafficking, repeal the statutory presumptions, and provide resources to strengthen institutional integrity and accountability. The judiciary should give and publish written reasons for sentences in capital and serious drug cases, and give weight to the offender’s prospects of rehabilitation. The executive should replace punitive anti-drug messaging with evidence-based health education, and ensure that people in custody have access to drug treatment and mental health care. Together, these measures would move Malaysia towards a public health approach to drugs while keeping offenders accountable.